How Appraisal Works
Policies differ, but most appraisal clauses follow the same basic steps:
- Either side demands appraisal in writing.
- Each side names its own appraiser, often within 20 days. The appraiser usually must be competent and independent or impartial, depending on the policy’s wording.
- The two appraisers select an umpire. If they cannot agree, many policies let either side ask a court to appoint one.
- Each appraiser estimates the loss. Where they disagree, they submit their differences to the umpire.
- An award agreed to by any two of the three sets the amount of loss.
Under most policies, each side pays its own appraiser and the two sides split the umpire’s fees.
Appraisal Has Consequences Beyond the Number

What Appraisal Decides, and What It Doesn't
Appraisal decides the amount of loss: what it costs to repair or replace the damaged property and, in many cases, how much of the damage a covered event caused versus other causes. Texas courts regularly enforce appraisal clauses, even when the parties also disagree about coverage.
Appraisal generally does not decide whether the policy covers the loss, whether the insurer handled the claim properly, or how much is owed after deductibles, prior payments, and policy limits. Those questions remain for negotiation or a court.
The Insurance Company Demanded Appraisal. Now What?
- Check the deadline. Many policies give you a short window, often 20 days, to name your appraiser.
- Choose your appraiser carefully. The appraiser’s experience, independence, and documentation will shape the result.
- Keep the other issues in view. Coverage disputes, earlier underpayments, and claim-handling problems may need to be preserved and pursued separately.
- Ask for an itemized award. An award that separates covered and uncovered damage, replacement cost and actual cash value, and code-upgrade items prevents later fights over what the number includes.
- Get advice before you respond. How you respond, or whether you respond at all, can affect your other rights.
Appraisal as Part of the Larger Strategy
Review the Policy
Read the appraisal clause, deadlines, appraiser requirements, and related conditions.
Evaluate the Dispute
Decide whether the disagreement is really about the amount of loss, or about coverage, causation, or claim handling.
Build the Record
Assemble estimates, photographs, expert reports, and the claim file before the panel meets.
Select the Appraiser
Help choose a qualified, independent appraiser and, when needed, an umpire.
Guide the Process
Address scope, allocation between causes, and itemization through the award.
Act on the Award
Review the award and payment, calculate any interest owed, and pursue remaining claims when warranted.
Insurance Appraisal FAQs
If the policy has an appraisal clause, Texas courts generally enforce it. Courts rarely find the right to appraisal was waived, and pending coverage or bad-faith disputes usually do not stop it.
Yes. Policyholders can usually demand appraisal under the same clause. Whether you should depends on whether the dispute is really about the amount of loss, and what other claims you may give up.
Under most policies, each side pays its own appraiser and the two sides split the umpire’s fees. Policies vary.
An award is generally binding as to the amount of loss. Courts set aside awards only in narrow circumstances: when the appraisers exceeded their authority, when the award resulted from fraud, accident, or mistake, or when it was not made under the policy’s terms.
Generally, no. Appraisal decides the amount of loss. Coverage questions are resolved by the parties or a court, though appraisers may allocate damage between covered and other causes.
Payment generally resolves the contract dispute over the amount of loss. The insurer may still owe interest if it paid late, and other claims may remain depending on the facts. Review the payment and any release before signing.
